EU Unlocks €16.4 Billion for Hungary
The sum equals roughly 14 percent of yearly state spending, released as the bloc rewards a decisive pro-European shift at the ballot box.
Begin with a question plain enough to sound naive, the sort that ought to have a dull, technical answer: what does a country have to do to deserve its own share of the European budget?
For the better part of a decade, the European Commission had a dull, technical answer. Hungary’s funds were frozen because the country had failed specified rule-of-law conditions: courts that bent the right way, public procurement that leaked, an anti-corruption apparatus that corrected nothing in particular. Deserving was a checklist. The items on it were documents; the documents could be audited; the audits did not care who had won the last election. It was bloodless, and slow, and faintly humiliating to the country on the receiving end, and it carried one quiet virtue, which was that it meant the same thing on a Tuesday as it had meant the Monday before.
This week the answer quietly changed verbs, and the substitution went by almost unremarked.
Péter Magyar, a month past beating Viktor Orbán, stood beside Ursula von der Leyen as she announced that over €16.4 billion in frozen funds would be released, subject to reforms agreed that same afternoon. He admitted he had not hoped for so much so soon. (When the recipient of a windfall volunteers that he is surprised by its size, the admission is usually worth keeping.)
Listen to the words, because the people being covered wrote most of them.
They made a clear choice. They chose democracy. They chose to return to the heart of Europe, von der Leyen said. Notice the geography in that sentence. Hungary did not move. The heart of Europe did not move. The borders sit where they sat a year ago and so do the budget lines. What moved was the verb fastened to the same population: last spring they did not qualify, this spring they deserve, and between the two springs the only measurable change is the name of the prime minister.
The mechanism is built to look rigorous. The moment the rule of law reform passes the parliament, the moment the money tied to that milestone can be disbursed, von der Leyen said. A milestone, a reform, a disbursement: it has the grammar of conditionality. It is also weightless, because Magyar holds a commanding majority and the reform will pass the way water passes downhill. (Goodhart, who noticed that any measure attached to a reward stops measuring much, would recognise the shape of it.) The milestone is real on paper and a formality in the room.
Then the figure that does the actual talking. Magyar put the package at 14% of the Hungarian budget.
Fourteen percent. Roughly a seventh of everything a mid-sized European state spends in a year, arriving in a single parcel, handed across a table by an institution that had spent years insisting it could not be moved by politics.
He was careful about that last point, careful in the way that gives the game away. The unfreezing, he insisted, had nothing to do with the EU summit in June, where talks on Ukraine’s membership bid open their first cluster.
There was absolutely no link between the unfreezing of the funds and the opening of the first cluster of talks, he said.
No one in the room had asked him to deny a link in the particular sentence he chose to deny it. Denials tend to arrive pre-loaded with the accusation they answer; a man who volunteers the precise thing that did not happen has usually just named the thing everyone is thinking.
There is the word again, doing all the work, carrying fourteen percent of a national budget on its back. A year ago deserve described a failure to qualify. This week it describes an entitlement. Same people, same ledgers, the verb flipped clean over while the vocabulary of rigour around it, milestone, reform, conditionality, stayed politely in place.
June is already on the calendar. The first cluster of talks on Ukraine’s accession needs unanimity, which in plain terms means it needs Budapest, the capital that under the last government made vetoing things its signature foreign policy. Budapest has now been shown, on camera, the going rate for cooperation and the size of the parcel it comes in. The reform will pass; the majority is commanding. The money will move; the milestone is a formality. And when the summit opens, the Commission may well discover that the heart of Europe has room in it for precisely as much as the budget can fund.
Expect another clear choice. Expect, when it arrives, to be told it was deserved.
References:
Hungary’s Magyar has ‘unlocked’ €16B in EU cash. Getting it is another story.